Qesem Cave (Israel) : 400,000-year-old 'School of Rock' Found
Flint tool school? Rocks that hominin kids seem to have practiced on suggest that modern humans may have developed much earlier than thought
Ariel David
Source - https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/.premium-1.824356Archaeologists may have uncovered the oldest known prehistoric school, where it seems young hominins were taught how to make flint tools, butcher animals, and master other skills necessary to survive in the Stone Age about 400,000 years ago. The discovery is so remarkable that the scientists are wondering whether it means Homo sapiens itself evolved much earlier than is currently thought.
The notion that what they found was evidence of an early teaching system is based on analysis of hundreds of flint stones and fragments found in Qesem Cave, in central Israel, a spot that hominins called home from 400,000 to 200,000 years ago.
The discovery may attest that our ancestors developed complex cultural patterns, such as language and knowledge transmission, much earlier than believed. That in turn adds to mounting evidence from around the world that has already pushed back the clock on the evolution of modern humans by at least 100,000 years, and challenged the idea that Homo sapiens developed in Africa.
“I wouldn’t talk about a school in the modern sense, but we can see a specific tradition, a specific way of doing things in the cave, which was passed on from generation to generation,” says Ella Assaf, an archaeologist and PhD student at Tel Aviv University who is leading the study. “There was definitely a mechanism of knowledge transmission.”
Limb bones of animals found in Qesem Cave, where primitive men of some type lived, and made and used flint tools Courtesy of Ruth Blasco and Jordi Rosell
Assaf, who has been digging at Qesem since 2010, analyzed hundreds of flint items looking for signs of different skill levels by the prehistoric knappers.
“Knapping is complex. It requires many different motor and cognitive skills, as well as technical and practical knowledge,” she told Haaretz. “The idea was to see if we can identify the different stages in this learning process."
Assaf, who has been digging at Qesem since 2010, analyzed hundreds of flint items looking for signs of different skill levels by the prehistoric knappers.
“Knapping is complex. It requires many different motor and cognitive skills, as well as technical and practical knowledge,” she told Haaretz. “The idea was to see if we can identify the different stages in this learning process."
Now you try this, Oggie
Among the most telling finds are flint cores that show signs of having been used by multiple people, some of whom were clearly highly skilled, while others were just beginners, Assaf explains.
"Cores" are pieces of flint that were first shaped into specific forms, according to the desired tool, and were then struck to detach flakes that formed the tool itself: a blade, a scraper, a spear point and so on. A skilled knapper could detach multiple tools from the same core, "peeling" layer after layer from the stone, in a sort of prehistoric version of mass production.
The detachment would leave a scar on the core. By looking at this scar – effectively a negative image of the detached tool – researchers can tell if the process was completed successfully.
Flint core reflecting highly skilled knapping Pavel Shrago
Many of the cores at Qesem, so called “shared cores,” display mixed results, Assaf says. On the same stone, she can point to clean scars left by a perfectly detached flake as well as multiple signs of breakages, mistakes and failures.
“If it were just one mistake, we wouldn’t know, since even experienced knappers make mistakes, but if I see repeated errors I can think that it was someone else, two different hands that knapped the same core,” she says.
Flint core reflecting low skill knapping Sasha Flit
This is extraordinary because, for one thing, good flint was not readily available at Qesem. Researchers have found the precious raw material had to be quarried and transported from sites that were between five to 15 kilometers away.
Flint core reflecting two generations of item removals ("shared core") Sasha Flit
“You can say that someone had one nice core and decided to throw it away, and then someone less skilled picked it up and reused it,” Assaf says. “But it’s unlikely that so many good quality cores would be discarded and just lie around. They could have used them for making good tools, instead of having to go outside the cave to find new flint.”
The most likely explanation for this phenomenon is that it was part of a teaching process to help children learn knapping skills, Assaf says.
Further supporting her theory is the fact that these shared cores have not been found randomly strewn across the cave but concentrated in a few spots, especially around the main hearth. This is consistent with the idea that there were specific areas where learning activities were more common, something that is also common around the hearths of contemporary hunter-gatherer tribes, she notes.
Flint core reflecting low skill knapping Pavel Shrago
There are other signs of learning in Assaf’s sample of flints: half-finished or badly made tools as well as artifacts made with low-quality materials, which an expert knapper would never have selected or spent time working on.
Assaf, together with Tel Aviv University archaeologists Ran Barkai and Avi Gopher, published preliminary results of her research last year in the journal Quaternary International, and hopes to complete her PhD thesis on the subject in 2018.
Spanish researchers have also studied the cut marks left by flint tools on the bones of butchered animals at another site, Bolomor Cave in Valencia, Spain, noting that they appear consistent throughout the 200,000 years of human habitation at the cave, again suggesting that standardized techniques – of butchering in this case – were passed down through generations.
